The Rebrand That Backfired: Jaguar’s Lesson in Misreading Identity

Change feels powerful. But when you erase the very identity people love, you risk losing more than attention - you lose trust.

The Bold Leap: A Rebrand Designed to Shock

In November 2024, Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) pulled off a radical reinvention. The iconic leaping jaguar “growler” logo was retired, replaced with a minimalist, mixed‑case “Jaguar” font and a new tagline “Copy Nothing”. The accompanying campaign, a 30‑second clip featuring androgynous models, colorful visuals, and slogans like “Create Exuberant,” “Live Vivid,” and “Delete Ordinary” - made no mention or showing of a car .

The aim? To reposition Jaguar as a fearless, all‑electric luxury brand by 2026. But the result was a campaign that left its heritage in the rear‑view and alienated the very audience that revered it .

An Identity Without Roots: Why It Fell Apart

Recognition Matters:

The “growler” was more than a logo - it was shorthand for Jaguar’s character. Removing it destroyed a key mental shortcut, leaving customers untethered.

No Cars, No Story:

An ad campaign devoid of cars - especially from an automaker - left audiences baffled about what, exactly, the brand stood for.

Emotion Turned Cold:

Critics like Sue Benson pointed out that the campaign felt “cold and aloof,” stripped of sentiment and legacy - emotions that typically drive luxury car purchases.

Fallout: Sales, Strategy, and the C-Suite Shake-Up

Sales Tank

Europe saw a staggering 97.5% drop in April 2025, with just 49 Jaguars sold, down from 1,961 a year earlier . Though JLR partially blamed the pause in producing internal‑combustion models, the timing of the slide made the rebrand a convenient lightning rod .

Agency Ouster

Jaguar promptly reevaluated its marketing partners. Accenture Song - behind the rebrand - found itself on the chopping block as JLR reviewed its ad agency relationships .

CEO Departure

Adrian Mardell, who steered Jaguar through its most profitable year in a decade and nine consecutive profitable quarters, announced his retirement after 35 years with the company. His exit was widely linked to the backlash from the rebrand.

In a sign of deeper shifts under JLR’s parent, Tata Motors, P.B. Balaji - its finance chief - will become the first Indian CEO of Jaguar Land Rover, stepping in November 2025 .

Political Firestorm

The campaign didn’t just spark consumer outrage; public figures like Donald Trump labeled it “seriously woke,” questioning its effectiveness and branding it “disgraceful.” Elon Musk even cheekily asked on social media: “Do you sell cars?” .

Learning from Jaguar: Three Key Takeaways

  1. Don’t erase your brand’s soul for sensationalism. Heritage isn’t just old; it’s emotional equity. Boldness is good, but if it’s built on erasing that identity, you risk annihilation.
  2. Make sure your message has substance behind the flash. Modern aesthetics are great - if they signal something real. Skip the flash, and your message rings hollow. Change needs testing and listening—before the wave becomes a backlash.
  3. Brand reinvention demands strategic empathy. Take your audience with you. Alienate them, and leadership can lose its footing.

The Long Game: Rebirth or Rebound?

Jaguar may yet recover. Its pivot to an all‑electric lineup has potential—but the timing and messaging were misaligned. The upcoming electric models, now delayed into 2026, need to bridge the emotional gap this rebrand tore open .

Final Thought:

Reinvention Wins When It Respects What Came Before

Small changes made consistently are more powerful than grand gestures made once.

Jaguar’s move was a grand gesture, and one that overlooked the emotional through-line that built the brand. Rebranding isn’t about erasing history. It’s about writing a new chapter that still feels like yours.

Continue reading
Insights